| 1949 | Joe Jordan | AP 3rd team |
| Bob Healey | AP 3rd team |
| 1950 | Bob Schloss | AP 2nd team |
| Bob Healey | AP 3rd team |
| 1951 | Joe Jordan | AP 2nd team |
| Bob Schloss | AP 3rd team |
| 1953 | Zippy Morocco | AP 1st team |
| 1955 | Murphy McManus | AP 3rd team |
| 1960 | Phil Simpson | AP 3rd team |
| 1961 | Phil Simpson | AP 2nd team |
| 1962 | Allan Johnson | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd teams |
| 1964 | Jerry Waller | AP 2rd team |
| Jimmy Pitts | AP 3rd team |
| 1965 | Jimmy Pitts | Coaches 2nd, UPI 2nd, AP 3rd teams |
| Jerry Waller | UPI 3rd team |
| 1966 | Jerry Waller | UPI 3rd, AP Hon. Mention |
| Ray Jeffords | AP Hon. Mention |
| 1967 | Jim Youngblood | UPI 3rd, AP Hon. Mention |
| Dick McIntosh | AP Hon. Mention |
| 1968 | Bob Lienhard | AP 2nd, UPI 2nd, Coaches 2nd teams |
| Ray Jeffords | UPI 3rd, AP 2nd, Coaches 2nd teams |
| 1969 | Bob Lienhard | UPI 1st, AP 2nd, Coaches 2nd teams |
| Jerry Epling | AP 2nd, UPI 2nd teams |
| 1970 | Bob Lienhard | AP 1st, UPI 1st, Coaches 1st |
| Lanny Taylor | AP 2nd, Coaches 2nd, UPI 3rd teams |
| Jerry Epling | UPI 2nd team |
| 1972 | Ronnie Hogue | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd teams |
| John Fraley | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 3rd teams |
| 1973 | Tim Bassett | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd teams |
| 1975 | Jacky Dorsey | AP 1st, Coaches 1st, UPI 2nd teams |
| 1976 | Jacky Dorsey | AP 1st, UPI 1st, Coaches 1st teams |
| Walter Daniels | AP 3rd teams |
| 1978 | Walter Daniels | AP 2nd team |
| 1976 | Walter Daniels | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd teams |
| Lavon Mercer | AP 3rd team |
| 1980 | Lavon Mercer | AP 3rd team |
| 1981 | Dominique Wilkins | AP, UPI, Coaches, Players 1st |
| 1982 | Dominique Wilkins | AP, UPI, Coaches, Players 1st |
| 1983 | Vern Fleming | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 3rd |
| Terry Fair | AP 3rd, UPI 3rd |
| 1984 | Vern Fleming | AP, UPI, Coaches 1st teams |
| 1985 | Cedric Henderson | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd |
| 1986 | Joe Ward | Coaches 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 3rd |
| Donald Hartry | AP 3rd, UPI 3rd |
| 1987 | Willie Anderson | AP 1st, Coaches 1st, UPI 2nd |
| 1988 | WillieAnderson | Coaches' 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd |
| 1989 | Alec Kessler | Coaches' 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd |
| 1990 | Alec Kessler | Coaches' 1st, AP 1st, UPI 1st |
| Litterial Green | Coaches' 1st, AP 2nd, UPI 2nd |
| Rod Cole | AP 3rd team |
| 1991 | Litterial Green | Coaches 1st, AP 1st, UPI 2nd |
| Rod Cole | All-SEC Defensive Team |
| 1992 | Litterial Green | Coaches 1st team, AP 2nd team |
| Reggie Tinch | AP 3rd, All-SEC Defensive Team |
| 1993 | Charles Claxton | Coaches' 2nd team |
| 1995 | Carlos Strong | AP 3rd team |
| Shandon Anderson | Coaches' 3rd team |
| 1996 | Katu Davis | Coaches, AP 3rd team |
| Shandon Anderson | AP 3rd team |
| 1997 | Michael Chadwick | Coaches' 2nd team, AP 3rd team |
| Ray Harrison | AP 3rd team |
| 1998 | Jumaine Jones | AP Co-Freshman of the Year, Coaches & AP 3rd team |
| G.G. Smith | Coaches' 3rd |
| 1999 | Jumaine Jones | AP & Coaches' 1st team |
| D.A. Layne | SEC All-Freshman |
| 2000 | Anthony Evans | AP 2nd team, Coaches' 3rd team |
| D.A. Layne | AP 2nd team |
| 2001 | D.A. Layne | AP 1st team, Coaches' 2nd team |
| Anthony Evans | AP 3rd team |
| 2002 | Jarvis Hayes | AP & Coaches' 1st team, AP SEC Newcomer of the Year |
| Ezra Williams | AP 2nd team, Coaches' 3rd team |
| 2003 | Jarvis Hayes | AP & Coaches' 1st team |
| Ezra Williams | AP 2nd team, Coaches' 3rd team |
| 2004 | Rashad Wright | AP, Coaches' 2nd team, SEC Defensive Player of the Year |
| Levi Stukes | SEC All-Freshman team |
| 2006 | Mike Mercer
| SEC All-Freshman team |
| 2007 | Sundiata Gaines | Coaches' 2nd team |
| 2008 | Sundiata Gaines | Coaches' 2nd team, SEC All-Defensive Team |
| Jeremy Price | Coaches' SEC All-Freshman Team |
2009
| Trey Thompkins | Coaches' SEC All-Freshman Team |
2010
| Trey Thompkins | AP & Coaches 1st team |
2011
| Trey Thompkins | Coaches' 1st team, AP 2nd Team |
| Travis Leslie | Coaches' 2nd team |
| 2012 | Kentavious Caldwell-Pope | SEC All-Freshman Team |
